The group created an initial questionnaire from a brain storming exercise and then spent some time honing it resulting in a questionnaire that is felt covers the vast majority of issues.
As an exercise the group chose two websites each that they considered were good and bad examples. It was suggested that they not choose all of the sites from the original website analysis. Using the questionnaire they created group members evaluated each others sites and from this analysis it would prove 1) if their questionnaire was fit for purpose and 2) would this result in the expected outcome.
Below is the comments made by each group member in relation to their good and bad website choice along with their completed peer reviewed questionnaire's. Finally analyses of the questionnaires are made scoring them to determine their overall rating.